Corridor of a European data center with server racks

European sovereignty isn't marketing: it's code

2 min read

Half of European startups say "GDPR-friendly" and then run everything on AWS us-east-1 with OpenAI embeddings. Here I explain exactly what runs where in Memchats, and why we made it more expensive to operate but more honest.

by Equipo Memchats

Table of contents
  1. An overused word
  2. Where every bit runs in Memchats
  3. Why it costs more
  4. Problems it solves

An overused word

The phrase "digital sovereignty" has been so overused in European pitch decks it doesn't mean anything anymore. Any startup with a .eu domain and a GDPR disclaimer uses it. But open the code, look at the DNS, read the logs: most run the critical logic in American data centers and depend on APIs from US companies for everything important.

Padlock on a closed laptop by a window

Where every bit runs in Memchats

Postgres and Redis: Hetzner Online in Falkenstein, Germany. The database runs without disk encryption, and we say so on the security page. Private internal connection between containers. If Hetzner goes down, Memchats goes down.

Embeddings: bge-m3 self-hosted, as our own service and not a third-party API. We don't use the OpenAI API or Voyage. Self-hosting is operationally more complex, but the text of the embeddings is not sent to any outside provider.

Object storage: original files are stored in Cloudflare R2, with Western Europe as the preferred location. That is a location hint, not an EU jurisdiction guarantee: Cloudflare does not contractually commit that the files stay in the EU.

The model: here is a real compromise. The provider is Google (Gemini), which we reach through our model gateway, and we cannot guarantee from here which region Google processes each request in. It only receives the context needed to answer, not your whole history.

Woman holding her phone protectively on a European street

Why it costs more

Self-hosting embeddings costs compute 24/7. Self-hosted Mailcow requires maintenance. Hetzner needs more DevOps than click-deploy on Vercel. But the question isn't "what's easier to operate", it's "what promise can I keep when I look in the eye of a user who trusts me with messages from their ex during a custody case".

If the answer is "honestly, almost everything is in USA but we signed a DPA", then you're not doing sovereignty. You're doing marketing.

Problems it solves

This piece exists for situations like these: a WhatsApp message that ends up in court.

Start with your own chats

Import one conversation and Alma builds that person’s profile in a minute. Free to start.

Create my free account

Keep reading